Saint Vincent
The newest Sandals, on a private cove
Sandals Saint Vincent is the wild-card pick: newer build, dramatic coastline, and a southern-Caribbean location with lower storm risk than Jamaica.
Argyle International is about 15 minutes away. Most US guests connect; there is rarely a true nonstop from the mainland.
Hurricane profile: low. Southern Windwards, similar to Grenada and Barbados: official season still runs June–November, but climatological risk is lower than Jamaica or the Bahamas. Dry season January–April.